Winter 2024 - The unfinished reviews

 These three shows did not get their own review yet, even thought Winter 2024 is closed down and we have moved on. One day, I might look back at this... but probably not.

Still, they need something so my soul can rest.
This is the way to do it - one article, three shows, review speedrun! [See bottom of the post for Legend.]

╭────────── · 𓆩🌻𓆪 · ─╮
╰─ · 𓆩🌻𓆪 · ──────────╯


Metallic Rouge

Genres: Action - Mystery - Sci-Fi
Studio: bones
Season: Winter 2024

-----------------------------------------------------------------

Metallic Rouge might have been a great show, but it didn't work out at all. With amazing visuals, mid character design and bad storyline it makes up for the biggest disappointment and total confusion of the season.

Science fiction is a great way to go all out on your ideas... but if your ideas are all over the place, you really won't say anything and just disappoint your fans.

Someone grab this universe, write a good fanfiction and give this amazing idea a story that is deserving. Metallic Rouge could have been something, but remains nothing.

Review speed run

Story: [2]
Art: [6]
Animation: [8]
Characters: [6]
Music: [8]
Entertainment value: [4]


Conclusion: not recommended 👎

╭────────── · 𓆩🌻𓆪 · ─╮
╰─ · 𓆩🌻𓆪 · ──────────╯

Meiji Gekken: 1874


Genres: Action - Drama - Mystery
Studio: Tsumugi Akita Anime Lab
Season: Winter 2024

-----------------------------------------------------------------

I am so sad that this was so bad, it makes me really upset.
Meiji Gekken had everything - historical period drama, love story, political conspiracy...

The art was decent, the animation could be really great... But there was another, bigger problem. If you saw Bucchigiri, read my review or got into contact with it in any way, you know the anime sometimes overdid it with content presented per one episode. Well, Meiji Gekken took it even further.

With episode length moving around 30 minutes, no proper opening or ending... each episode did a lot more than it was supposed to. Feeding us confusing mix of three main plotlines - Shizuma looking for Sumie; Sumie's revenge; Shuragami's conspiration - and many more smaller plots... - the anime got lost in itself.

Watching it felt like you missed a previous season. Not knowing who the characters were, what was their purpose or what period we're in and what the setting is...

It was predictable in the worst way possible - that means, you weren't held in suspense because you were either trying to understand what was going on or you knew what would happen word after word. The ending that was supposed to be the most heartbreaking scene you ever saw felt like a relived exhale of authors & animators that it's finally over...

I wish I could recommend this, I wish I could say something nice about this... but it's just not deserved.

Review speed run

Story: [4]
Art: [6]
Animation: [8]
Characters: [6]
Music: [x]
Entertainment value: [2]


Conclusion: not recommended 👎

╭────────── · 𓆩🌻𓆪 · ─╮
╰─ · 𓆩🌻𓆪 · ──────────╯

Yubisaki to Renren


Genres: Romance - Slice of Life
Studio: Ajiado
Season: Winter 2024

-----------------------------------------------------------------

Great romance, lovable characters and beautiful art. Yubisaki to Renren has it all. And not only that, but it also opens eyes (of all that are watching) to the world of deaf in a softest and easiest way possible. It makes you really think about certain aspects, it makes you think about how our society is set (that being not inclusive) and I doubt anyone was bored.
The only complain I have is about Itsuomi... I disliked the main boy character, but that is not the end of the world.

Every character has their little backstory and every character is lovable in their own way.
While I am sure this show won't have a second season and you're all better off reading the manga, please do it give it a shot, because it's a wonderful experience.

Review speed run

Story: [8]
Art: [10]
Animation: [10]
Characters: [8]
Music: [6]
Entertainment value: [10]


Conclusion: recommended 👍


╭────────── · 𓆩🌻𓆪 · ─╮
╰─ · 𓆩🌻𓆪 · ──────────╯
Legend:
10 - quite the masterpiece
8 - more enjoyable than others
6 - if it would be less awful, it would be great
4 - I did not get the appeal of this one
2 - really bad